Publication of data without permission

Case number: 
12-22

Case text (Anonymised)

A director of an institute in France has expressed concern about a paper published in our journal. One of the authors (not the corresponding author) of the paper, person A, visited his laboratory in France for 5 months in 2009 to carry out some work. The director says that some methods used and results obtained in his laboratory have now been included in the paper without his knowledge or permission. Researchers from another institute in a different country are co-authors of the paper, and the corresponding author is someone from that institute. The director in France acknowledges that the experiments could have been repeated in conjunction with this other group, but says that it is not very ethical to work in this way.

I would be grateful for any advice on how to proceed in this matter. We have replied saying that we would contact COPE for advice.
In 2010, the editor-in-chief of another journal contacted the French group about a paper submitted by person A which included several members of the French laboratory as co-authors without their knowledge and permission. That editor-in-chief was concerned about apparent falsification of data by manipulation of a gel photo, which the French group were able to confirm. They contacted person A and the departmental head but have had no response.

Follow up: 

The editor contacted the director in France who brought the case to their attention, and forwarded the recommendations of the Forum COPE, asking him how he would like to proceed. He asked the editor to try to contact person A to ask for an explanation. The editor emailed and sent a letter asking person A to respond. They are still awaiting a response.

Advice: 

The editor provided additional information that there was no formal contract between person A and the laboratory in France, and the director of the laboratory has replied that none of the data have been published previously.

The advice from the Forum was to contact person A, relaying the concerns expressed by the French institute, and ask for an explanation. If there is no response or an unsatisfactory response from person A, then the editor may consider contacting person A’s institution and asking them to investigate the matter. In the meantime, the editor may like to publish an expression of concern if an investigation is ongoing.
However, as the director acknowledges that the experiments could have been repeated elsewhere and if he cannot prove that the published results were actually produced in his laboratory, it may be difficult for the journal to pursue this further. Further advice was for the editor to encourage the French institute to take up the matter with person A and her current institute. Or the French institute could contact the corresponding author of the paper, and then he/she should then be responsible for putting together a response on behalf of all authors. If it turns out to be a simple matter of ‘scientific discourteousness’, a letter exchange would be a good way to publicly apologise.
Regarding the second paper, involving the other journal and possible falsification of the data, this should probably be set aside for the moment, in the interests of giving person A the benefit of the doubt. It is the other journal’s responsibility to pursue this matter.

Resolution: 
On-going
Year: 

Comments

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 21/7/2014 6.40am

The world is changing fast. people are also being changed.day by day we are becoming more dependant on degital system.yoU make me think of this really.You have a nice way of sharing your thoughts. High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy High Pagerank Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks
.EDU Backlinks
.GOV Backlinks
SEO Package

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 21/7/2014 7.29am

I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. I think it may be help all of you. Thanks.
how to be rich

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 21/7/2014 8.12am

I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. I think it may be help all of you. Thanks.
дизайн студия интерьера
дизайн интерьера Москва

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 21/7/2014 9.24am
  • Posted by Adi Tech, 21/7/2014 10.21am

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. social media marketing
High Pagerank Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy Backlinks
Buy Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 22/7/2014 8.53am

I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job. how to be rich
how to be rich
how to be rich
how to be rich

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 23/7/2014 12.52pm

I found this post very exciting. I think you will have any other post on this topic? I am also sending it to my friend to enjoy your working style. Cheers! hack facebook password

  • Posted by Alpha Gama, 24/7/2014 8.46am

I was also searching related stuff from long time.You have solved my problem.Thanks for sharing this great stuff with us High Pagerank Backlinks
High PR Backlinks

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 25/7/2014 11.43am

The world is changing fast. people are also being changed.day by day we are becoming more dependant on degital system.yoU make me think of this really.You have a nice way of sharing your thoughts.Generate Bitcoins Online

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 9/8/2014 9.21am

Hey there thanks for showing me this. I must say that your blogpost was the most enjoying read I've seen in a long time. Greetings from High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy High PR Backlinks
Buy Backlinks
Buy Backlinks
High Pagerank Backlinks
Buy High PR Backlinks
Buy High PR Backlinks
Buy High PR Backlinks

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 18/8/2014 6.18am

You could post on the friendless of the blog owner. You may illustrate it's mesmerizing. Your blog feedback may add to your contacts. home appliance warranty
home warranty providers

  • Posted by Adi Tech, 22/8/2014 10.52am

I want to thank you for this great and valuable information. asvab scores

Add new comment

Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.