Flowcharts

COPE's flowchart on what to do if peer review manipulation is suspected after publication. Related resource How to recognise potential manipulation of the peer review process…

COPE's flowchart on what to do if peer review manipulation is suspected during the peer review process. Related resource How to recognise potential manipulation of the peer review process…

Manipulation of the publication process is a relatively new form of misconduct affecting the publishing industry. These guidelines represent an important first step towards encouraging openness and collaboration between publishers to address this phenomenon. Systematic manipulation of the publication process is where an individual or a group of individuals have repeatedly used dis…

COPE's guide on how to recognise potential manipulation of the peer review process. It contains details on recognised features or patterns of reviewer activity and best practice recommendations on how to minimise peer review manipulation. Key points Peer reviewers may be suggested by: the Editor handling the manuscript; authors on submission of their manuscr…

COPE's guidance on what to consider when you are asked to peer review a manuscript, presented as a flowchart and laying out the steps in the decision process that you might go through to decide whether or not you should accept the request. Key points Consider the review model and evaluation criteria Consider potential conflicts of interest Consider whether…

…COPE Flowcharts COPE flowcharts offer a step by step process, for practical use on handling different aspects of publication ethics issues.  For ease of use, we have combined all of COPE's flowcharts into one downloadable PDF which includes the flowcharts listed below. Allegations of misconduct Reviewer suspected to have appropriated an author’s ideas or dat…

COPE's guidance as a flowchart on what to do if you suspect a reviewer has appropriated an author’s ideas or data. Key points The instruction to reviewers should state that submitted material must be treated in confidence and may not be used in any way until it has been published. Related resources

…This is all of COPE's flowcharts in Arabic. Other languages: Chinese | Croatian | English | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Chinese Other languages: Arabic | Croatian | English | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Croatian Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | English | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in French. Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Italian Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Japanese Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Persian Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Polish Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Spanish Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian | 

…This is COPE's flowcharts in Turkish Other languages: Arabic | Chinese | Croatian |